How to set up a Christmas bakery menu that takes orders without chaos.

A Christmas bakery order list is a short menu of holiday bakes that customers reserve ahead and pick up on a set day. A good one shows each item with its size and price, the last day to order, the pickup days and times, how payment works, and what's in each bake. Get those on one page and most of the phone calls answer themselves.

A chocolate yule log with meringue mushrooms and rosemary on a wooden board
Photo by Alex Diffor on Unsplash.

What goes on a Christmas order list?

Look at a few bakery pre-order pages and the same parts show up again and again:

  • The items, each with a size and a price. Sizes work best as servings, such as serves 8 to 10, not just large.
  • The order cut-off. One date and time, written in full.
  • The pickup days and hours. Usually two or three days just before Christmas.
  • Payment. Paid in full when ordering, a deposit, or pay at pickup.
  • Allergens and ingredients, per item.
  • How to order: in store, by phone, or both, with the number.

Many lists leave something out. A Colorado bakery's holiday list gives clear prices and dates but says nothing about payment. A market's yule log page skips servings, so a customer can't tell what Regular or Extra Large feeds. Each gap becomes a phone call in your busiest week.

Which bakes belong on it?

Keep it short. Choose things that sell at Christmas, travel well, and can be made in batches. Six to ten items is plenty for a small bakery. The classics:

  • Yule log, or bûche de Noël (boosh duh no-EL), French for "Christmas log." Wikipedia describes it as a sponge spread with icing, rolled into a log and iced again, most often with chocolate buttercream.
  • Stollen (SHTOL-en), the German Christmas loaf. Wikipedia calls it "a fruit bread of nuts, spices, and dried or candied fruit," and it's often filled with marzipan, so it carries nuts.
  • Panettone (pan-eh-TOH-nay), the tall sweet bread from Milan. Wikipedia notes that "The proofing process alone takes several days." That's why many bakeries cap how many they'll make and close orders early.
  • Mince pies, small English pies of dried fruit and spice. Traditional mincemeat can include beef suet, nuts and brandy, so say what's in yours. Sell them by the half dozen or dozen.
  • Breads and rolls for the Christmas meal, plus a cookie box or two.

Add one or two of your own specialties.

How do you set dates and deposits?

Work backwards from your oven. Count how many logs, loaves and pies you can bake and finish in the last three days before Christmas. That number is your limit.

Then set dates:

  1. Order cut-off. Pick a date that leaves time to buy ingredients and plan the bake. Panettone needs the earliest cut-off of all.
  2. Pickup days. Many bakeries use December 23 and 24 only. One Colorado market's yule log page says that "pick-up is available only on December 23 and 24."
  3. Pickup slots. Morning or afternoon slots spread the line out on Christmas Eve.
  4. Early pickup for things that keep. Stollen, panettone and boxed cookies can go home a week early. That frees shelf space for the cakes.

Add a limit too, like orders close December 17 or when we're full. It's honest, and it gets people ordering early.

Then pick one payment rule and write it in a single line. Paid in full when ordering means almost no one fails to show. A deposit with the rest at pickup suits phone orders, and a fixed amount per order is easier to explain than a percentage. Pay at pickup is easiest for the customer, but you carry the risk of unclaimed cakes. Say what happens if plans change, for example changes until December 17, deposits not refunded after that. Give each customer a written copy of their order with the pickup day and slot.

Allergen notes that answer the questions

At Christmas, customers buy for a whole family, often with one guest who can't eat nuts or gluten. Mark each item, not just the page. The FDA lists the major food allergens as "milk, eggs, fish, Crustacean shellfish, tree nuts, peanuts, wheat, soybeans, and sesame." For a bakery, wheat, milk, eggs, tree nuts and soy cover most of the list.

Add one plain line about cross-contact if you can't keep allergens apart, and say who to ask. Our guide to allergens on menus shows how to write those lines.

A sample Christmas order list

Christmas orders 2026Example only

Order in store or by phone · Orders close Wednesday, December 17, at 5 pm, or when we're full

Pickup: Tuesday, December 23, and Wednesday, December 24, 8 am to 2 pm. Choose a morning or afternoon slot.

Yule log, chocolate, serves 6 to 8$42
Yule log, chocolate, serves 10 to 12$62
Yule log, chestnut and coffee, serves 6 to 8$46
Stollen with marzipan, 1 lb loaf$22
Panettone, 2 lb, limited to 40$38
Mince pies, half dozen$16
Mince pies, dozen$30
Christmas cookie box, about 24 cookies$34
Dinner rolls, dozen$10

Contains: yule logs (wheat, milk, eggs; chestnut log also tree nuts), stollen (wheat, milk, eggs, almonds), panettone (wheat, milk, eggs), mince pies (wheat, milk; vegetable suet; brandy), cookie box (wheat, milk, eggs, may contain nuts).

Stollen and panettone can be picked up from December 15.

Deposit of $10 per order when ordering by phone. Balance at pickup.

These prices are an example. Check them against your own costs. Our free bakery profitability calculator shows what each item leaves you after costs.

Put the list where customers check it

Print the order list for the counter, with a QR code so people can read it at home before they call. With Menupresso, the Christmas list can be its own menu, separate from your everyday one. Each item can carry several labeled prices for its sizes, and dietary labels like Nut-Free. Write the cut-off, pickup and deposit rules in the section introduction. When the panettone sells out, switch on Hide from guests and press Publish changes. Menupresso doesn't take orders or payments, so orders still come in at the counter and by phone. The menu link never changes, so the printed QR code works until Christmas Eve. For layout ideas, see our bakery menu example and QR menus for bakeries.

Sources

Put your Christmas list online.

List each bake with its sizes, prices and allergens, and keep one QR code on the counter until Christmas Eve.

Create a free menuSee a bakery menu example