Which drinks belong on a Christmas list?
Pick drinks that guests expect at Christmas, and that your team can serve fast when the room is three deep at the bar. Most of the list should be poured from a batch, not built one by one.
| Drink | How you serve it | Make ahead? |
|---|---|---|
| Mulled wine | Hot, from a kettle | Yes, the whole drink |
| Mulled cider | Hot, from a kettle | Yes, the whole drink |
| Eggnog | Cold, from the fridge | Yes, the base |
| Spiced Old Fashioned | Over ice | Yes, the whole drink |
| Sparkling by the glass | Cold, from the bottle | Only the syrup or garnish |
| Hot punch, no alcohol | Hot, from a kettle | Yes, the whole drink |
Six drinks is enough. Add one house special if you have a bartender who wants to make one, but keep the rest of the list fast.
Mulled wine, mulled cider and a hot punch without alcohol
Wikipedia describes mulled wine as "an alcoholic drink usually made with red wine" that is served hot, and notes that "It is usually served at Christmas markets in Europe." In Germany it's called GlĂĽhwein (GLUE-vine), roughly "glow wine."
Use a fruity, inexpensive red. Warm it with orange slices, cinnamon sticks, cloves, star anise and some sugar. Heat it gently and don't let it boil: boiling drives off alcohol and can make the spices taste bitter. Hold it in a soup kettle or a large slow cooker on low, with a lid, and ladle it into heatproof glasses with handles.
A note for US menus: "apple cider" usually means unfiltered apple juice, with no alcohol. Write hard cider if the drink has alcohol, so nobody orders the wrong one. Mulled hard cider takes the same spices, with less sugar.
Drivers, families and guests who aren't drinking want something that feels like Christmas too. In Germany, Wikipedia notes, "the non-alcoholic Kinderpunsch is offered on Christmas markets, which is a punch with similar spices." For your version, warm apple juice, cranberry juice and orange with the same spices, plus a few slices of fresh ginger. Keep it in its own kettle, with its own ladle and a clear label. Price it as a real drink, not as a soda.
Eggnog: safe, and still fast
Eggnog is the drink most likely to slow the bar down and the one most likely to make a guest sick. Make the base the day before, cooked and chilled.
Food Safety News, a trade news site, puts it plainly: "To be sure that any Salmonella is killed in eggnog, the mixture must be cooked to an internal temperature of 160 degrees F." It adds that "the alcohol in the drink does not kill bacteria." Iowa State University Extension gives the same advice and says FoodSafety.gov "recommends a cooked egg base for eggnog." Pasteurized eggs are the other safe route.
At service, pour the chilled base into a glass, add the bourbon, rum or brandy, and grate nutmeg on top. Label and date the container, and follow your local health rules on how long you keep it.
The spiced Old Fashioned and sparkling by the glass
A spiced Old Fashioned is the easiest cocktail to batch. Make a syrup with sugar, water, cinnamon, cloves and orange peel. Per drink, use 2 oz bourbon, 1/4 oz spiced syrup and 2 dashes of bitters. For a bottle-sized batch, that's about 16 drinks from a liter of bourbon.
Stirring over ice normally adds water, so a batch needs that water added up front. Death & Co's guide to batching cocktails puts it at around 20 to 25% of the drink. Add the water, chill the bottle, and pour over a large cube with an orange twist.
Sparkling wine works the other way. The same guide says "Carbonated cocktails (like spritzes or French 75s) should be topped to order." So prepare only the extras: a cranberry syrup, sugared rosemary, sliced orange. A 750 ml bottle gives five 5 oz glasses, so offer it by the glass and by the bottle.
Put the list where guests can see it
A seasonal list changes often: the eggnog runs out, a new special arrives, and the whole thing ends in January. In Menupresso, put the drinks in their own section at the top of your menu, give the prosecco two labeled prices (glass and bottle), and mark the house special as New. When the eggnog runs out, the Hide from guests switch takes it off until the next batch. Press Publish changes and guests see it straight away, through the same QR code that's already on your tables.